Menupickcom lists publicly available information. We are not affiliated with the restaurants shown. How we source and check listings

Menupickcom

Simply Greekalicious menu

17 dishes across 5 sections Restaurant

Prices transcribed from the printed menu, last checked

Menu Simply Greekalicious photo menu 1
Photographed in store, August 2026. See all 4 pages

Photos of the printed menu

Photographed in store in August 2026. The dish list below covers everything we could read clearly; the full card has more.

Wraps 15 dishes

  • Honey Mustard Chicken US$11.95

    grilled chicken, lettuce, tomato & honey mustard

  • Greek Burrito US$12.95

    chicken, spicy feta, rice, avocado, tomato & onion

  • Chicken Caesar Wrap US$11.95

    romaine, parmesan cheese, caesar dressing & grilled chicken

  • Mediterranean US$12.95

    grilled chicken, romaine, tomato, cucumber, red onion, peppers, olives, feta cheese and our house vinaigrette

  • Chicken Club US$12.95

    grilled chicken, bacon, avocado, lettuce, tomato & pink sauce

  • Falafel Wrap US$10.95

    lettuce, tomato, onion, hummus & tahini

  • Grilled Shrimp Wrap US$12.95

    grilled shrimp, romaine, tomato, cucumber, red onion, peppers, avocado & pink sauce

  • Grilled Veggie Wrap US$10.95

    grilled veggies with lettuce

  • Gyro Lovers US$11.95

    gyro, lettuce, tomato, red onion & tzatziki

  • Halloumi Wrap US$11.95

    Halloumi Cheese, mesclun, tomatoes, cucumbers, red onions, avocado & lemon Tahini sauce

  • Athenian US$11.95

    chicken doner, lettuce, tomato, red onion & tzatziki

  • Grecian US$11.95

    chicken souvlaki, lettuce, tomato, red onion & tzatziki

  • Steakhouse US$16.95

    skirt steak, romaine, tomato, red onion & bleu cheese dressing

  • Philly Steak US$12.95

    our philly steak all wrapped up

  • Greek Salad Wrap US$10.95

    our Greek salad all wrapped up

Dips 5 dishes

  • Dip Combo US$24.95

    Tzatziki, hummus, spicy feta & pita bread

  • Tzatziki US$7.95

  • Tyrokafteri US$8.95

    Spicy feta dip.

  • Loaded Hummus US$11.95

    Hummus topped with chopped Tomatoes, Cucumbers, red onions, pepperoncini , olives & Feta cheese.

  • Hummus US$7.95

Specials/ Greek Boxes 13 dishes

  • Greek Box Chicken Gyro US$16.95

    Chicken gyro over rice or FF , LTO, olives ,feta all in one box Pita & tzatziki

  • Greek Box Falafel US$15.95

    Falafel over rice or FF , LTO, olives ,feta all in one box Pita & tzatziki

  • Greek Box Pork Souvlaki US$16.95

    Pork Souvlaki over rice or FF LTO, olives, feta, pita & tzatziki

  • Greek Box Lamb/Beef US$16.95

    Lamb/beef gyro over rice or FF , LTO, olives ,feta all in one box Pita & tzatziki

  • Crispy Chicken Pita SP US$10.99

    Crispy Chicken Lettuce, Tomato, Red Onion & BBQ sauce

  • Greek Tacos SP US$10.99

    Handcrafted on fluffy mini pita. Authentic flavors. Guacamole , feta, chipotle chicken, pork al pastor, shrimp, pico and our Pink sauce.

  • Gyro Sand & Fries SP US$15.99

  • Greek Box Crispy Chicken US$15.95

    Crispy Chicken over rice or FF , LTO, olives ,feta all in one box Pita & tzatziki

  • Greek Box Grilled Shrimp US$19.95

    Grilled shrimp, L,T,O, Feta Olives, rice of FF pita Nad tzatziki sauce all in one box

  • Chicken Tenders (3) & Fries SP US$10.99

  • Moussaka W/Rice & Salad. SP US$14.99

    Eggplant Casserole

  • Greek Bowls SP US$9.99

  • Greek Box Grilld Chicken US$16.95

    Lamb/beef gyro over rice or FF. LTO, olives, feta , pita & tzatziki

Platters 16 dishes

  • Souvlaki Combo Pork And Chicken Platter US$20.95

  • Moussaka US$22.95

    Eggplant Casserole

  • Pork Souvlaki Platter US$20.95

  • Lamb Souvlaki Platter US$25.95

  • Keftedakia Platter US$20.95

    Greek fried meatballs.

  • Chicken Souvlaki Platter US$20.95

  • Grilled Chicken Platter US$20.95

  • Lamb And Beef Gyro Platter US$20.95

  • Spinach Pie Combo Platter US$19.95

  • Loukaniko Platter US$20.95

  • Falafel Platter US$19.95

    served with hummus & tahini

  • Lamb/Beef Gyro & Chicken Doner Platter US$21.75

  • Grilled Shrimp Platter US$24.95

  • Surf And Turf Skirt Steak & Grilled Shrimp Platter US$28.95

  • Skirt Steak Platter US$27.95

  • Chicken Doner Gyro Platter US$20.95

Salads 6 dishes

  • Horiatiki Salad US$12.95

    Traditional greek salad. Tomatoes, cucumbers, red onions, kalamata olives, peppers and feta cheese tossed with evool and oregano

  • Caesar Salad US$10.95

    romaine, croutons, parmesan cheese tossed in our caesar dressing

  • Greek Salad US$10.95

    romaine, tomatoes, cucumbers, red onions, peppers, dolma, kalamata olives and feta cheese served with our house evoo vinaigrette.

  • Grilled Veggie Salad US$10.95

    our grilled Veggies over mesclun and cucumber

  • Halloumi Salad US$14.95

    Mesclun , tomatoes, cucumbers, red onions ,peppers, avocado & fried Halloumi cheese. Served w/ Lemon Tahini Dressing.

  • Mixed Greens Salad US$9.95

    Mesclun, tomatoes, cucumbers, red onion, Kalamata olives and peppers served with our house extra virgin olive oil vinaigrette dressing.

Soup 3 dishes

  • Quart Of Soup (32 Oz) US$14.50

  • Avgolemono Soup 16oz US$7.50

    traditional greek egg, lemon chicken soup.

  • Lentil Soup (16 Oz) US$7.50

Greekalikious Combos 3 dishes

  • Souvlaki Feast Combo US$79.95

    10 pork or chicken skewers, pita bread, tzatziki, fresh cut fries, greek salad and 1.25 liter soda

  • Family Style US$109.95

    1/2 tray lamb/beef & chicken gyro, 1/2 tray rice or french fries, 1/2 tray greek salad, pita bread & tzatziki, (12) loukoumades with honey cinnamon

  • Gyro Lovers Combo US$64.95

    choice of 4 gyro sandwiches (lamb, beef or chicken doner), fresh cut fries, greek salad and 1.25 liter soda

Skewers 3 dishes

  • Lamb US$8.50

  • Pork US$6.25

  • Chicken US$6.25

Sandwiches 17 dishes

  • Grilled Chicken Sandwich US$11.95

    Served w/lettuce, tomato, red onion & tzatziki sauce

  • Skepasti US$17.95

    Gyro panini. Choice of beef/ lamb gyro or chicken doner, lettuce, tomato, red onion, tzatziki, french fries and mozzarella all pressed between 2 pitas

  • Chicken Bacon Ranch Sandwich US$11.95

  • Crispy Chicken Pita US$10.95

    Crispy Chicken Lettuce, Tomato, Red Onion & BBQ sauce

  • Pork Souvlaki Sandwich US$11.95

    Served w/lettuce, tomato, red onion & tzatziki sauce

  • Lamb And Beef Gyro Sandwich US$11.95

  • Buffalo Bleu US$11.95

    Chicken Donner Buffalo Sauce topped with creamy Bleu cheese

  • Falafel Sandwich US$10.95

    Served with hummus & tahini

  • Philly Steak Pita US$12.95

    Philly steak with peppers & onions topped with melted American cheese

  • Loukaniko Sandwich US$11.95

    Served w/lettuce, tomato, red onion & tzatziki sauce

  • Lamb / Beef Gyro & Chicken Doner Sandwich US$12.95

  • Grilled Shrimp Sandwich US$13.95

    Served w/lettuce, tomato, red onion & tzatziki sauce

  • Skirt Steak Sandwich US$16.95

    Served w/lettuce, tomato, red onion & tzatziki sauce

  • Chicken Souvlaki Sandwich US$11.95

    Served w/lettuce, tomato, red onion & tzatziki sauce

  • Lamb Souvlaki Sandwich US$13.95

    Leg of lamb chunks lettuce, tomato, red onion & tzatziki

  • Chicken Doner Gyro Sandwich US$11.95

    Chicken doner, lettuce, tomato, onion & tzatziki sce

  • Keftedakia Sandwich US$11.95

    Served w/lettuce, tomato, red onion & tzatziki sauce

Appetizers 22 dishes

  • Mozzarella Sticks (6) US$10.95

  • Greek Tacos (Chicken) US$11.99

    Handcrafted on fluffy mini pita. Authentic flavors. Guacamole , feta, chipotle chicken, pico and our Pink sauce.

  • Zucchini Sticks US$10.95

    with tzatziki

  • Greek Tacos (Pork) US$11.99

    Handcrafted on fluffy mini pita. Authentic flavors. Guacamole , feta, chipotle pork al pastor , pico and our Pink sauce.

  • Greek Nachos US$17.95

    pita chips with lamb/beef or chicken topped with lettuce, & tomato, onion, feta, olives, pepperoncini & tzatziki

  • Buffalo Wings (6) US$10.95

    regular, crispy or glazed in our buffalo sauce served with bleu cheese

  • Dolmathakia (6) US$8.50

    stuffed grape leaves with rice & herbs

  • American Sampler US$40.95

    (6) mozzarella sticks, (6) buffalo wings. (6) chicken fingers served with fresh cut fries and dipping sauces

  • Greek Tacos (Shrimp) US$11.99

    Handcrafted on fluffy mini pita. Authentic flavors. Guacamole , feta, chipotle shrimp , pico and our Pink sauce.

  • Spanakopita US$9.25

    Spinach pie

  • Keftedakia US$12.95

    Greek seasoned fried meatballs served with lemon and tzatziki

  • Halloumi Sticks US$12.95

    Fried semi-hard Cypriot cheese served w/ Lemon Tahini sauce

  • Grilled Shrimp Appetizer US$12.95

    with pink sauce

  • Pita Chips US$8.95

    served with tzatziki sauce or tirokafteri.

  • Feta Cheese US$9.95

    drizzled in evoo & oregano.

  • Mini Souvlaki (4) US$16.95

    marinated pork or chicken skewers. Served with pita bread and tzatziki

  • Chicken Fingers (5) US$11.95

    serves with honey mustard or bbq sauce.

  • Loukaniko US$12.95

    Greek pork sausage with leeks served with lemon and tzatziki

  • Fried Calamari (Kalamarakia) US$15.95

    served with lemon and red sauce

  • Greek Sampler US$49.95

    lamb & beef gyro, chicken doner, loukaniko, marinated pork & chicken cubes, fresh cut fries, served with pita and tzatziki sauce

  • Spinach Pie Triangles (4) Or Cheese Pie Triangles (4) US$10.95

    served with tzatziki sauce

  • Falafel (6) Appetizer US$9.95

    ground chickpea balls with herbs & spices and hummus & tahini sauce

Desserts 10 dishes

  • Revani (Semolina Cake) US$7.95

    semolina cake in light syrup

  • Fried Oreos (5) US$7.95

  • Greek Zeppoles (Loukoumades) US$6.95

  • Rice Pudding US$4.95

  • Greek Yogurt US$6.95

  • Baklava Cheesecake US$7.95

  • Chocolate Temptation US$5.95

  • Portokalopita US$6.95

    Greek orange Fillo cake. Fluffy and colorful soaked in a delicious orange scented syrup.

  • Galaktoboureko (Custard Pie) US$7.95

  • Baklava US$6.50

    With chocolate drizzle

Extras 5 dishes

  • Small Tzatziki US$1.25

  • Pita Bread US$1.25

  • Small Pink Sauce US$1.25

  • Whole Wheat Pita Bread US$1.50

  • Small Red Sauce US$1.25

Charbroiled Angus Burgers 12 dishes

  • Grilled Chicken Burger US$8.95

  • Philly Steak Burger Deluxe US$15.45

    peppers, onion and cheese. With lettuce, tomato, pickles & fresh cut fries.

  • Falafel Burger Deluxe US$14.00

    hummus, lettuce, tomato and pickle. With lettuce, tomato, pickles & fresh cut fries.

  • Greek Burger Deluxe US$15.45

    feta, tomato and onion. With lettuce, tomato, pickles & fresh cut fries.

  • Philly Steak Burger US$9.95

    peppers, onion and cheese

  • Cheeseburger US$9.95

    choice of American or Mozzarella.

  • Falafel Burger US$8.50

    hummus, lettuce, tomato and pickle

  • Classic Burger US$8.95

    lettuce, tomato and pickle

  • Cheeseburger Deluxe US$15.45

    choice of American or Mozzarella. With lettuce, tomato, pickles & fresh cut fries.

  • Grilled Chicken Burger Deluxe US$14.45

    With lettuce, tomato, pickles & fresh cut fries.

  • Greek Burger US$9.95

    feta, tomato and onion

  • Burger Deluxe US$14.45

    With lettuce, tomato, pickles & fresh cut fries.

Beverages 13 dishes

  • Coffee US$2.00

  • Greek Frappe US$4.95

  • Cans US$1.75

  • Bottled Water US$1.75

  • Stewarts US$3.25

  • Greek Specialty Drink US$3.00

  • 20 Oz. Bottles US$3.25

  • Classic COKE Glass Bottle US$3.25

    The cold, refreshing, sparkling classic that America loves.

  • Sour Cherry Lemonade US$5.00

  • Iced Coffee US$4.50

  • Snapple US$3.25

  • Fresh Lemonade US$4.00

  • 1.25 Liter Sodas US$4.75

Uncle Louie G Italian Ice 11 dishes

  • Mango Ice Pint US$12.50

  • Blue Ice Pint US$12.50

  • Cherry Ice Pint US$12.50

  • Spumoni Ice Pint US$12.50

  • Strawberry Ice Pint US$12.50

  • Orange Creamsicle Ice Pint US$12.50

  • Chcolate Ice Pint US$12.50

  • Lemon Ice Pint US$12.50

  • Watermelon Ice Pint US$12.50

  • Rainbow Ice Pint US$12.50

  • Coconut Ice Pint US$12.50

Sides 16 dishes

  • Grilled Chicken Side US$10.95

    marinated by Greekalicious.

  • Gyro Fries US$14.95

    French Fries topped w/ Gyro ( Lamb/Beef or Chicken Doner) and Feta cheese.

  • Sweet Potato Fries US$7.50

  • Lemon Potatoes US$8.50

  • Bacon Cheese Fries US$11.95

  • Rice US$6.50

  • Greek Fries US$9.95

    with crumbled feta and oregano

  • Curly Fries US$7.50

  • Grilled Veggies US$8.50

  • Philly Steak Fries US$15.95

    Philly steak, onions, peppers and cheese sauce

  • Lamb And Beef Gyro Side US$10.95

    shaved spiced lamb and beef served with pita & tzatziki

  • Fresh Cut Fries US$6.50

  • Greek Salad Jr. US$7.95

    Served w/ pita

  • Onion Rings US$7.50

  • Cheese Fries US$8.50

  • Chicken Doner Side US$10.95

    marinated shaved chicken, served with pita & tzatziki

Kids Menu 6 dishes

  • Chicken Tenders (3) & Fries US$12.95

  • Gyro & Fries Plate US$12.95

  • Mozzarella Sticks (4) & Fries US$12.95

  • Cheese Quesadilla & Fries US$12.95

  • Souvlaki & Fries Plate US$12.95

    Pork or Chicken

  • Hamburgers & Fries US$12.95

About these prices

Restaurants change prices without notice, and a menu photographed in August may already be out of date. Treat these figures as a guide, not a quote. If you spot a difference, tell us and we will re-check it.

Other menus in Wantagh

Prices transcribed the same way, each with the date last checked.

All Wantagh listings
Menu Directions